Colour Science & Perception
what the eye settles, and what it cannot
Concept

Chromaticity plane — where it appears

The particular set of coordinates a chromaticity diagram is drawn in, of which the discipline has published a dozen. Each is a nonsingular combination of the observer's three functions, so all of them describe the same matches — and an area measured on one differs from the same area on another by up to a factor of four and a half.

Named by 5 essays across 3 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

The locus and the triangle, drawn on one of the diagrams. The spectral locus and the sRGB triangle in CIE xy (1931) — the default of the discipline, and the default used here. The triangle covers 33.6% of the enclosed area here. Nothing about the observer or the display has changed between this picture and any other in the family; the coordinates have, and the coordinates are what an area is measured in.

The diagram has no area

A chromaticity diagram is a projective picture of a three-dimensional space, and the freedom colour matching leaves in the observer acts on it as a projective map. Straight lines and mixture ratios survive that; area, distance and angle do not — so half of what the diagram is used to say is a statement about the paper.

matching · Gamut What share of the diagram the sRGB triangle covers, in twelve published coordinate systems. Each row is a chromaticity diagram somebody has printed, and each bar is the fraction of the enclosed visible area that the sRGB triangle covers in it. Every row describes exactly the same observer and exactly the same gamut. The answer runs from 8.5% to 38.4%, a factor of 4.52, because area is not preserved by the projective maps that carry one of these diagrams to another. The familiar "about a third" is a fact about CIE xy.

Two thirds is not a property of the eye

It has been said from the beginning here that about two thirds of the chromaticity diagram cannot be shown on a screen. The figure is right, on the diagram it was measured on, and across twelve published diagrams the same triangle covers anything from 8.5 to 38.4 per cent of the same locus. Counting stimuli instead gives an answer that does not move.

matching · Gamut MacAdam's ellipses, drawn on one diagram. The twenty-five measured discrimination ellipses at 10× actual size, on CIE xy (1931). Mean axis ratio 2.95 — one would mean every contour is a circle — and a size spread of 10.42 between the largest and the smallest. Both numbers depend on the plane, which is why the 1976 revision existed; neither can be taken to one, which is why the revision did not finish the job.

No diagram makes them circles

Every chromaticity diagram is a projective picture of the same measurement, so how badly MacAdam's ellipses fail to be circles can be minimised over the whole family of them. The best plane there is still leaves the average ellipse twice as long as it is wide — which makes the residual a fact about the eye rather than about anybody's choice of primaries.

difference · Metric Which of this collection's own claims survive a change of basis, and which are about the paper. Nine sentences this site says, sorted by whether they mean the same thing after the observer's three curves are replaced by a nonsingular combination of themselves. 5 of the nine do. The four that do not are not thereby wrong — they are statements about a chosen set of coordinates, and they are true of those coordinates. What they cannot be is statements about the eye, which is how every one of them is usually read.

Which of these is a convention

Nine ordinary sentences from this collection, put through one test — do they mean the same thing after the observer's three curves are replaced by a nonsingular combination of themselves? Five survive and four do not, and none of the four is wrong, because each is a statement about a set of coordinates being read as a statement about an eye.

limits · Limits Five answers to how far the ellipses are from circles. Five mean axis ratios on the same twenty-five measured ellipses, measured the same way in every row: the boundary points carried through, the longest radius over the shortest, averaged. What differs is which class of map is allowed. The first two rows are chromaticity diagrams, which divide by a sum; CIE xy as printed leaves 2.95 and the best diagram there is leaves 2.02. The last three are lightness–chroma spaces, which divide by a white point; CIELAB as specified leaves 3.44, the best space with no compression leaves 2.33, and the best space with a cube root in it leaves 1.61. Neither family contains the other, and only the last one gets below two.

A compression goes below the floor

Elsewhere this collection minimised the anisotropy of MacAdam's ellipses over every chromaticity diagram there is, found 2.02, and called the residual a property of the eye. It is a property of the eye seen through a projective picture. A cube root after the right basis reaches 1.61 on the same twenty-five ellipses.

difference · Metric

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

IdentifiabilityInvarianceProjective transformationCIELABDiagram conventionsGamutMacAdam's ellipsesPerceptual uniformitySpectral locusUniform chromaticity scaleAdditive mixtureAssertion

All concepts