Every essay — page 42
What light is What the eye does Matching and measuring Difference and uniformity What the brain does What a scene does What a camera does Where the model breaks What it takes to deliver it
SeriesObserversNamed objectsRefutationsSearch
What it takes to deliver it
A colour that stays where it was measured is nobody's problem. This is the apparatus that carries one to somebody else — ink on a sheet, a profile, a rendering intent, a proof, and a room — and every stage of it is a map that loses something, chosen deliberately.
A profile interpolates light
A profile is exact at its patches and wrong between them, and how wrong has been measured twice. Which way it is wrong has not. At a nine-step lattice the mean signed lightness error between the nodes is +0.136 against a mean colour difference of 0.133 — the error is not a scatter but a bias, and it lightens. The repair costs nothing measured and is forbidden by how a profile is checked: let the table be wrong at its own patches.
The scale hangs from one measurement
Black point compensation is a straight line between two blacks, and the destination's is a measurement of one patch at the darkest place a spectrophotometer is ever asked to read. The lightness scale's slope is 903 units per unit of luminance factor there and 43 at the paper, so a thousandth of a reflectance is worth nine tenths of a lightness unit at the black and four hundredths at the white. That one number moves a mid grey by nearly a quarter of a delivery tolerance, and no specification names it.
The inverse table errs dark
A profile's forward table predicts a print lighter than the press makes, and refitting its nodes removes the bias. The table a colour engine actually uses to separate an image is the other one — the inverse, from colour to ink — and it errs the opposite way: filled exactly from the press it asks for too much ink and prints dark, and built by inverting the ordinary forward table it prints darker still. Inverting the refitted forward table removes the inherited part and leaves the inverse's own. The round trip through both tables improves only when each is refitted against its own error, and then the two are no longer each other's inverse.
The eye counts a corner's error, not its peak
A Lanczos-magnified patch errs a fifth more at its corner than along its edges, pixel by pixel, and an unsharp mask errs almost exactly as much at its corner as along its edges. Filtered by the eye over the plane rather than along a line, the two swap: the magnified corner is seen exactly as its edge is, and on a printed page the sharpened corner is seen at 2.4 times its edge. What decides it is whether the error changes sign. Ringing averages away and a one-sided halo does not, and a corner is where two edges' halos land on the same patch of retina.
Sharpened type errs on its dark side
A sharpened square hides its halo along its edges and shows it at its corners, so a sharpened page of type was predicted to show its error at the corners of its letters, several times out of proportion to their length. Black type does the opposite: its outer corners and stroke ends hold between two thirds and nine tenths of their share. As the eye leaves it, the error lies on the dark side of every edge, and a corner holds as much of it as it has dark ground around it — a quarter of a disc where a black corner points out into paper, three quarters where black wraps round a pale one.
A strategy keeps the refit only where black prints
Refitting an inverse table's nodes against their own error halves it, and in a four-ink table the refit has to leave the separation strategy's choice of black alone. Held to the strategy, it keeps the whole of its gain wherever the strategy prints black and almost none of it where the strategy does not — and the share it keeps equals the share of the grey ramp printed with black, to within three hundredths. The start of black generation, predicted to be where the refit would fail, is where the table needs it least.
A serif moves the error and adds little
When a scanned page is sharpened on its stored values, the error the eye sees lies on the dark side of every edge, so black sans-serif type does not gather it at its corners. The worry was that a serif changes that: every stroke end gains a bar and every bar an inside angle, the configuration where large letters did gather error. It does not. Black serif type's brackets hold three quarters of their share of the error and its serif tips half. Reversed, the serif tips hold two and a half times theirs. Across both, serifs lengthen the outline by a tenth and the error by a few per cent — they move it, and in black type away from the corners.
A little black ends the cast
A four-ink inverse table errs by a warm cast along the grey axis wherever the separation strategy prints only three inks, and almost only in lightness wherever it prints black. Real strategies start black gently, and the gentle start was expected to keep the cast until black carried much of the grey. It does not. The cast falls to a tenth of its three-ink size once black supplies a tenth to a sixth of the grey's darkening, at every toe from nothing to thirty units wide — because inside the toe the table's chord runs along the trade of black against the other three inks, which errs in lightness. What the toe does cost is the segment where black begins, which goes from the table's best to its worst.
A hairline spills its error onto the paper
Sharpening a scanned page on its stored values errs on the dark side of every edge, which is why black type's serifs hold less than their share of the error at text sizes. A hairline serif, a tenth of a stem, was expected to change that at display sizes: its dark side is so thin that the halo would wrap its corners. It does not. From 12 to 48 point, black type's hairline tips hold a third to three fifths of their share, less than slab serifs' tips, and the share falls as the letter grows. What gathers at display sizes is the junction of bar and stem, with or without serifs — and where the scan lands the letter against the pixels moves a tip's share more than its size does.
The cast returns where black is steep
Below a black-generation toe a four-ink table's grey picks up a small cast again, up to a third of the three-ink cast at the widest toe, and the explanation offered was the jump in black's curvature where the toe ends. It is not. A toe whose curvature is nothing at its end returns exactly the same cast, segment for segment, and a kink put into straight black casts in its own segment once in twelve tries. What the returned cast follows is how steep black has to be once the toe is done — how far the chromatic inks climbed while black was held back, and how fast they then have to come down.