Colour Science & Perception
what the eye settles, and what it cannot
Concept

Noise — where it appears

The random scatter of a measurement around its true value, from photon arrival and from the electronics that read it. Averaging removes it only while its mean stays zero, which a gain or a matrix preserves and a clip at zero does not.

Named by 5 essays across one field — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

A camera's dye widths are free under one requirement and not under another. Three panels, one per dye. In each, a pair of bars per requirement: how far that dye's centre wavelength and its bandwidth can move before the requirement gets five per cent worse. Under the adaptation objective — the one the previous round measured — every width has far more room than its centre, which is the finding that put a tolerance budget on the centres. Throughput and the colour matrix's noise gain, the two requirements that objective was said to be silent about, reach the edge of the search in every direction and hold nothing. What tightens the widths is the Luther residual, which was in the model already. The bottom pair in each panel is what survives all four.

The widths were free because nothing else was asked

A camera's three dye bandwidths carry almost all of the flattest direction of the adaptation objective, so that objective says a tolerance budget belongs on the centre wavelengths. The two requirements it was said to be silent about turn out not to bind either — and the one that does was in the model already.

imaging · Capture Noise clipped at zero, averaged over a shadow, under tungsten. A grey ramp from black to ten per cent reflectance under tungsten, captured at three illustrative noise levels, with every negative raw reading set to zero before the readings are averaged over an area. Each line is the colour difference between that average and the noiseless grey. At high gain a half per cent grey is 1.04 off and a black frame 0.79; at very high gain the worst is 2.95, at 1.0 per cent. The same readings averaged before any clip come back exactly, at every level. The tint is gone once every channel sits several deviations above zero.

Clipped noise does not average away

Noise on a raw reading is as likely to fall below the true value as above it, which is why averaging an area removes it. A converter that sets negative readings to zero keeps the upper half and throws the lower away, and the mean of what is left is the signal plus a pedestal. With no black level error anywhere, a half per cent grey under a tungsten lamp comes out 1.04 colour differences off at high gain, 8.98 after a four-stop push — and a blur that removes every trace of the noise leaves the tint where it was.

imaging · Capture The statistic a converter would read, under each model. The log ratio of the two channels that are still open, against how bright the surface is, under the two models of what a highlight is. A matt surface over-exposed keeps its own ratio exactly — the line is flat, and it must be, because scaling every channel by the same amount leaves a ratio alone. A glossy surface carries a reflection of the lamp on top of its body colour, so its ratio slides towards the lamp's as the reflection strengthens: -0.086 of a log unit between a quarter of full scale and nine tenths. That slide is the whole of the evidence a converter has for choosing between them.

The converter can choose except where it matters

A converter rebuilding a clipped highlight has to say whether the surface was matt and over-exposed or glossy and carrying a reflection, and the evidence is whether its raw chromaticity slides towards the lamp's on the way up. Read through the sensor's own noise, the slide is clear on most of the chart from the few tens of pixels a specular highlight holds — and on the surfaces where it takes half a frame, confusing the two models costs more than the median. A ratio cannot see a common scale, and an exposure supplies one.

imaging · Capture The four places a clamp could sit are two pipelines. Every pair of clamp positions, with the largest difference their delivered values reach over a grid of raw inputs that includes negative ones. Two of the six are exactly zero: a clamp at zero commutes with the white balance, which is a positive scale applied channel by channel, and with the tone curve, which is monotone and fixes zero. It does not commute with the colour matrix, which is the only step that mixes the channels — so the four positions collapse to two, before the matrix and after it, and no measurement of any scene can say more than which side a converter is on.

Four places to clamp are two pipelines

The essay on clipped noise ended on a procedure: a black frame and a dim grey card at a high amplification would place each raw converter's clamp. A procedure is a claim that a measurement identifies something, and this one identifies less than it looks. A clamp at zero commutes with the white balance and with the tone curve and not with the colour matrix, so the four positions are two pipelines — and the measurement separates them, on a card at half a per cent of white rather than on the black frame.

imaging · Capture The same chart in two studios and in the room that holds both lamps. Each of the chart's twenty-four surfaces, with the pixels its slide needs at two standard deviations at high gain, on a logarithmic scale. Lit by a 3000 K radiator alone the worst surface needs 16,194; lit by daylight at 6500 K alone, 139,574. Lit by both, 50 and 50 per cent of the light, with a highlight of each lamp read together, the worst needs 10 and the median 6. The studios' hard surfaces sit at different places on the chart, and no surface is hard in both.

Two lamps decide what one lamp could not

Under one lamp a handful of surfaces cannot tell a glossy highlight from a matt over-exposure without most of a frame, because there the two differ by a scale a ratio cannot see. In a room lit evenly by a 3000 K lamp and daylight, every surface on the chart is decided from ten pixels. A body can sit at one lamp's white, not at two, and the rescue holds only while the second lamp carries a fifth of the light and its white sits far enough from the first.

imaging · Capture

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

Camera rawSignal-to-noiseClippingIdentifiabilityWhite balanceCamera sensorDeclared inputDichromatic reflectionHighlight recoveryShot noiseSpecularCamera sensitivity

All concepts