Colour Science & Perception
what the eye settles, and what it cannot
Concept

Reproducibility — where it appears

Whether the same inputs and the same recorded settings produce the same result twice, in different hands and at different times. It is the property a file format and a profile are for, and it fails wherever an operation reads something the record does not carry — the order of a pipeline's steps, the variable an average is taken in, or the set of colours a document contained.

Named by 4 essays across 2 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

Three exchanges, two of which move the colour. The documented pipeline is a white balance, a colour matrix, a tone curve and a clip. Each bar is what happens when two neighbours change places, over 30 surfaces the modelled sensor captures: the filled bar is the mean and the tick is the worst patch. Exchanging the balance and the matrix costs 9.2 colour differences at the mean and 13.2 at the worst. Exchanging the curve and the clip costs exactly nothing, and that is a theorem rather than a small number: a monotone curve onto the unit interval commutes with clamping to it.

The order is not in the documentation

A raw converter performs a white balance, a colour matrix, a tone curve and a clip, and every account of the process lists them in that order without saying the order decides anything. Exchanging the first two moves the picture by nine colour differences at the mean and thirteen at the worst patch. The twenty-four arrangements collapse into five outcomes running out to sixty-five, and nothing a converter ships says which of them it is.

imaging · Capture The same highlight, clipped in two places. A ramp running from inside the sensor's range to 1.6 times over it, clipped at the sensor and clipped after the matrix. Below the ceiling the two are identical to the floating-point floor. Above it they part, reaching 21.0 colour differences and 78 degrees of hue. Clipping late keeps a highlight neutral and clipping early keeps its hue, and converters do both.

Two converters and one highlight

The clip is the only step in a raw pipeline that destroys information rather than moving it, and it is the step whose position varies most between converters. Below the sensor's ceiling its position changes nothing at all, exactly. Above it, clipping at the sensor and clipping after the matrix land twenty-one colour differences and seventy-eight degrees of hue apart, and which hues are affected is a property of the camera's own dyes.

imaging · Capture The same colour, delivered from two documents. A ramp of chroma, mapped into a press's gamut under the perceptual intent from two source solids: the whole of sRGB, and the same solid with its chroma limited, which is what a document containing only muted colours amounts to. Under a colorimetric intent the two answers are identical to the floating-point floor. Under the perceptual one they are 0.69 apart at the mean and 2.64 at the worst, on colours the destination could hold either way.

An intent is not a function of the colour

A rendering intent is chosen per job and applied per pixel, which suggests it is a function of the colour. The colorimetric ones are, exactly — the same colour from two documents comes out identical to the floating-point floor. The perceptual one is not — it compresses the whole source solid into the destination, so the same colour delivered from a wide document and from a muted one lands 2.6 colour differences apart, on colours the destination could hold either way.

applied · Delivery Out to the device and back, once and again. Each intent applied 3 times in succession to the same ramp. The upper bar is what the first pass moves and the lower is what the second moves. relative-colorimetric is idempotent — the second pass moves nothing, to the floating-point floor — and the other two are not: perceptual moves another 2.73 and saturation moves another 3.09. A file converted twice is not a file converted once.

A second conversion is not a repeat

A colour converted to a device and back is described as lossy where the device cannot hold it and exact where it can, which suggests that a colour surviving one round trip survives any number. One of the four intents is idempotent to the floating-point floor. The other two are not — a perceptual conversion moves a ramp 3.70 colour differences on its first pass and another 2.73 on its second, and after three passes it is still moving by 2.42.

applied · Delivery

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

Colour managementSpecificationDeclared inputThe ICC profileStructural choiceClippingGamut mappingTransfer functionChromaColour spaceConvergenceDisplay gamut

All concepts