Three exchanges, two of which move the colour
Drawn at its defaults, in the order the operations happen in. It takes no options at all, so every essay calling it gets this exact drawing.
Called by 11 essays
the blast radius of changing it
The order is not in the documentation
A raw converter performs a white balance, a colour matrix, a tone curve and a clip, and every account of the process lists them in that order without saying the order decides anything. Exchanging the first two moves the picture by nine colour differences at the mean and thirteen at the worst patch. The twenty-four arrangements collapse into five outcomes running out to sixty-five, and nothing a converter ships says which of them it is.
What a camera doesOne step has no choice
Four of a raw converter's operations can be arranged twenty-four ways. The reconstruction cannot be arranged at all — a colour matrix needs three numbers and a mosaic site has one, so filling in the mosaic is forced to the front by arithmetic rather than by convention. What is not forced is whether it happens in linear light or after the curve, and that decision costs 5.8 colour differences at an ordinary edge and nothing at all four sites away from it.
What a camera doesA contrast control is three controls
A tone curve is a function of one number at a time and knows nothing about hue. Applied to each channel separately it rotates a hue circle by up to seventeen degrees, raises chroma by a factor of 1.27 at ordinary strength, and lifts lightness — so a photographer who moves a contrast slider has moved three things and the interface names one of them. All three scale with the curve's strength, monotonically, and the hue rotation depends on which hue it is.
What a camera doesA stop is not a stop afterwards
Doubling the light is exactly a factor of two in raw values and in tristimulus values, which is the one thing about exposure everybody is sure of. A stop taken after the tone curve is a factor of something else, and matching the two on an eighteen per cent grey leaves the rest of the frame between three and four colour differences apart at the mean and up to eleven at the worst patch. The gain that matches one stop is 2.47 rather than 2.
What a camera doesTwo converters and one highlight
The clip is the only step in a raw pipeline that destroys information rather than moving it, and it is the step whose position varies most between converters. Below the sensor's ceiling its position changes nothing at all, exactly. Above it, clipping at the sensor and clipping after the matrix land twenty-one colour differences and seventy-eight degrees of hue apart, and which hues are affected is a property of the camera's own dyes.
What a camera doesA black level is multiplied by the balance
Every raw value carries a pedestal that is subtracted before anything else, and a white balance is then a different gain in each channel. Subtracting a constant and multiplying by one commute only when the constant is zero or the gains are equal. So a pedestal left three thousandths of white too high becomes 2.4 colour differences in a two per cent grey, most of it chroma, in the colour the lamp starves — and pushing that shadow four stops in editing makes it 8.9. An offset in proportion to the lamp's own white is the exception, and it is exactly grey.
What a camera doesClipped noise does not average away
Noise on a raw reading is as likely to fall below the true value as above it, which is why averaging an area removes it. A converter that sets negative readings to zero keeps the upper half and throws the lower away, and the mean of what is left is the signal plus a pedestal. With no black level error anywhere, a half per cent grey under a tungsten lamp comes out 1.04 colour differences off at high gain, 8.98 after a four-stop push — and a blur that removes every trace of the noise leaves the tint where it was.
What a camera doesFilling in a highlight is a claim about the surface
A converter that rebuilds a clipped channel has to say what the highlight was. A matt surface over-exposed keeps its own colour, and filling the lost channel from that colour is exact. A glossy highlight is the surface's colour plus a reflection of the lamp, and the same fill leaves it 7.6 colour differences too colourful — while a fill that solves for surface and lamp is exact. Neither works once two channels are clipped, and a tungsten lamp keeps a highlight in the one-channel band more than twice as long as daylight does.
What a camera doesThe converter can choose except where it matters
A converter rebuilding a clipped highlight has to say whether the surface was matt and over-exposed or glossy and carrying a reflection, and the evidence is whether its raw chromaticity slides towards the lamp's on the way up. Read through the sensor's own noise, the slide is clear on most of the chart from the few tens of pixels a specular highlight holds — and on the surfaces where it takes half a frame, confusing the two models costs more than the median. A ratio cannot see a common scale, and an exposure supplies one.
What a camera doesFour places to clamp are two pipelines
The essay on clipped noise ended on a procedure: a black frame and a dim grey card at a high amplification would place each raw converter's clamp. A procedure is a claim that a measurement identifies something, and this one identifies less than it looks. A clamp at zero commutes with the white balance and with the tone curve and not with the colour matrix, so the four positions are two pipelines — and the measurement separates them, on a card at half a per cent of white rather than on the black frame.
What a camera doesTwo lamps decide what one lamp could not
Under one lamp a handful of surfaces cannot tell a glossy highlight from a matt over-exposure without most of a frame, because there the two differ by a scale a ratio cannot see. In a room lit evenly by a 3000 K lamp and daylight, every surface on the chart is decided from ten pixels. A body can sit at one lamp's white, not at two, and the rescue holds only while the second lamp carries a fifth of the light and its white sits far enough from the first.